The American Civil War
An Online Resource Guide

Religion and the American Civil War        Baptists and the American Civil War        Battlefields          Civil War Home

Battlefield Photos
Photos of Civil War
Battlefields and
more outdoor

Visit Colorado
Need a vacation?
Discover Colorado!

Home Furniture
Looking for new
furniture for your
home?  Browse
our online catalog.

National Parks
Learn about
America's national
parks and plan
your vacation.






Recent Historiography on Religion
and the American Civil War

by Bruce T. Gourley


Purchase your copy of Bruce Gourley's newest
book, Diverging Loyalties: Baptists in
Middle Georgia During the Civil War

" ... masterful ... will stimulate useful conversations among scholars and Civil War buffs alike."

" ... revisionist history of the best kind."

"... provocative ... comprehensive ... insightful analysis of an important epoch."

 Available December 2011
from Mercer University Press


             Religion and the American Civil War is an underdeveloped field of study which has received relatively little attention until recent years.  Previously considered a peripheral issue by most Civil War historians, religion emerged as a significant factor of the Civil War experience with the publication of Religion and the American Civil War (1998), a collection of essays edited by Randall M. Miller, Harry S. Stout and George Reagan Wilson.  Well-known historians such as Eugene D. Genovese, Daniel W. Stowell, Drew Gilpin Faust, Bertram Wyatt-Brown and Samuel S. Hill contributed to the ground-breaking volume.[1]

The 1994 religion and Civil War symposium in Louisville that led to the Religion and the American Civil War volume stands as a watershed event in terms of religion and Civil War historiography.[2]  However, a survey of Civil War historiography from the mid-1970s to the present provides the larger context in terms of recent historical attention given to religion and the Civil War.  Modern historians have approached the theme of religion and the Civil War in at least seven distinct, albeit sometimes overlapping, subcategories:  1) Religion in general during the Civil War, 2) Northern religion and the Civil War, 3) Southern religion and the Civil War, 4) Religion among the soldiers, 5) Civil War chaplains, 6) African-American religion and the Civil War, 7) Women and religion during the Civil War, and 8) Religious denominations and the Civil War. [3]

            Any discussion of the American Civil War must take into account the issue of slavery, the underlying cause of the War.  The sectional debates over slavery were frequently couched in religious language.  Modern historians addressing the relationship of religion and the Civil War typically focus on slavery as the one defining issue of antebellum religion.  As such, an important question begs our attention:  should historical literature pertaining to the larger antebellum and Reconstruction eras, but not the Civil War itself, be included in a historiography of religion and the Civil War?

The editors of Religion and the American Civil War focus on the period of the late antebellum era to early Reconstruction.[4]  The same timeline will be utilized in this paper.[5]  Nonetheless, the earlier antebellum era shaped the religious beliefs which would impact the Civil War.  Religion, especially of the Protestant variety, was an important factor in antebellum culture.  The Second Great Awakening of the early 19th century in particular greatly impacted American society.  This renewed interest in matters of faith led northerners to embrace a view of Christian perfection for individuals, a theology which in turn was applied to society in an effort to eradicate social ills.  Southerners, on the other hand, reacted to the revivals by assuming a faith of personal piety which focused on a literal reading of the Bible, but expressed little concern for addressing society’s problems.[6]  Historians are increasingly identifying these differing approaches to religious faith, and the actions resulting from these views, as playing a foundational role in the Civil War.  However, historians are only slowly recognizing the contributions of Catholics and minority religions in relation to the Civil War.[7]

In analyzing the historiography of religion and the Civil War, this essay will follow the order outlined in the seven subcategories previously introduced.  Accordingly, an analysis of religion in general is of first concern.

Continue to Religion in General and the Civil War


        [1] Randall M. Miller and others, Religion and the American Civil War (New York and Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1998).

        [2] Miller, Religion, v-vi.

[3] In instances where one work fits into multiple categories, I have determined which one(s) is more relevant.

        [4] Randall Miller also reinforced this definition of the Civil War era in terms of religion in an email received on 10/22/02.

        [5] Many works which explore religious themes of the larger era have focused on early abolition, the institution of slavery, the religious revivals of the 1820s and 1830s, or Reconstruction, rather than the Civil War per se.  These studies are important, but, with few exceptions, will not be utilized for the purposes of this paper.

       [6]  This brief sketch represents commonly accepted interpretations of the revivals which preceded the Civil War era.

        [7] Miller, Religion and the American Civil War, 286.  Miller notes that Catholics and minority religions tend to be ignored or given “short thrift.”